France Unbowed

The violence in France has been alluded to and condemned here, when similar events have unfolded in previous incidents. This is a violence in recent protests, that goes beyond the worst of the worst before. It is an odd thing to me, that, rather like America, too often, too violent, France, started its republic on a course of independence, with a violent revolution. “Vivre La France, Vivre La Revolution, ” are all too connected. Violence begets violence. This October unleashing of a bitterness of furious proportions, feels now like their own  Bolshevik October revolution.

Sometimes there is no substitute for what is called a just war. Much of the time it is an excuse for the hatred and harm caused by that very thing we deal with here, prejudice. Prejudice is at the centre of this often. And prejudice can be as much revealed as shared by groups of violent thugs, against individuals in government, as it can, by governments against individual citizens. Prejudices therefore perpetuate full blown and stereotypes then stay the course. It becomes cause and effect, it extends beyond the initial spark, a flame explodes and a vicious cycle of violence circles. What just cause for anger, can do, is become just a cause of further anger. Thus many of us amongst the progressive and humane are outraged, rather than involved, in the actions that develop from the grievances expressed. And lost in all of it is the cause of the original hurt. Inequality, poverty, divisions, prices, the things that are wrong are not put right by, in many ways, far worse outrages, than are experienced by the citizens of a great democracy. Even one founded on bloodshed.

Sir Peter Ustinov, who had a French wife and a Paris office, who detested the romanticising of the French revolution and disliked the glorifying of Napolean, is our instigator here, not of a campaign of  violence, but of a forum for the understanding of prejudice. And he said:

” No extreme fascinates me. I think it’s all wrong because it’s also too easy. These louts, anarchists or whatever they are, who go out into the streets to riot and break windows, don’t have to think any more…it gives them a great sense of communal core…in point of fact it’s the isolated voice which can’t even be heard in the crowd which is the most vital of all.” 

The overmighty French state, the statism of  a “where are your papers?” attitude, the policing not by consent always, but heavy handed often, the arrogance of Presidents or Prime Ministers, are not met well by chaos on a grand scale at best, and contempt for its great values at worst. France, unbowed, can make a stand against bowing and scraping on the national or international stage, but this call all be merely a show, if it does not mean it is a nation in good standing, that stands in good stead, tall and strong, at peace with itself and in harmony with its people.